The following is a paper on the book of James written for my New Testament Survey 2 class with Dr. DeKlavon
Plagiarism is defined as the wrongful appropriation, close imitation, or theft and publication, of another author’s language, thoughts, ideas, or expressions, and the representation of them as one’s own. You may NOT use any of my work for your own assignment.
The Book of James
—————————
A Paper
Presented to
Dr. David DeKlavon
Boyce College
—————————
In Partial Fulfillment
of the Requirements for BL 152 C
—————————
Micah N. Thornton
April 19, 2011
On my honor, I have neither give nor received improper assistance in the completion of this assignment.
the book of james
Introduction
The book of James is perhaps the most practical book in the New Testament. It is a book of applied wisdom for Christian living and no other book in the New Testament provides a clearer picture of faith in practice than the book of James. The book is full of instruction, rebuke, and encouragement similar to that of the teachings of Jesus. In fact, it is no exaggeration to call the book of James a practical commentary on the Sermon on the Mount.[1] For these reasons, the book of James is of indispensible value to Christians and to the Church.
Author
The book begins with these words: “James, a servant of God and of the Lord Jesus Christ” (1:1)[2]. But who is this James? Are there not several characters in the New Testament named James who could be possible authors of the book? There are at least four possibilities:[3] James the son of Zebedee (Matt 4:21), James the son of Alphaeus (Matt 10:3), James the father of Judas (Acts 1:13), and James “the Lord’s brother” (Gal 1:19).; James the father of Judas and James the son of Alphaeus can be immediately ruled out, simply because they are not very prominent in the New Testament. That leaves us with James the son of Zebedee and James the brother of Jesus. James the son of Zebedee did have a prominent role among the Twelve Disciples in the New Testament, but his martyrdom c. AD 44 (Acts 12:2)[4] rules him out (see Date of Writing). Having then narrowed the field down to James the brother of Jesus, we must examine his eligibility as the author.
Arguments for James’ Authorship
First of all, James the brother of Jesus is the most prominent James in the New Testament. Besides the fact that he was the half brother of Jesus, he eventually rose to become the ruling elder of the church of Jerusalem (Acts 12:17; Gal 2:9). Secondly, the book of James bears strong similarity not only with the Sermon on the Mount, but also with James’ language in Acts 15. For example, John MacArthur indicates that “the Greek infinitive verb chairein (“greetings”) appears in the New Testament only in James 1:1 and Acts 15:23.”[5] Thirdly, James has a particularly Jewish flavor to it with several references to the Old Testament, including four direct quotes. James is also the only New Testament author to use the title “Lord of Hosts” (5:4) for God; a title that is used for God 230 times in the Old Testament (Paul uses the term once, quoting from Isaiah). These Jewish characteristics of the book are consistent with James the brother of Jesus, who was a Jewish convert to Christianity, elder of the church in Jerusalem, and a member of the Jerusalem Council.
Arguments Against James’ Authorship
Some scholars have claimed that the Greek used in the book of James is too sophisticated for James, an uneducated Jewish peasant. They argue that the author of the book of James seems to use the Greek language with such style and ease that should it could not have come from the hand of an Aramaic speaking Galilean.[6] In response to this argument, we must not forget the strong influence of Hellenism in the Roman Empire that resulted in at least a bilingual Galilee. It is thus no irrational conclusion that James would have been competent in the Greek language. Furthermore, it would also be reasonable to conclude that James’ position as the head of the church in Jerusalem would require him to be competent in languages, as his position would have put him in regular contact with both Hebraic and Hellenistic Jewish Christians. One need not look any further than the Jerusalem Council to see an example of correspondence between James and Gentile Christians.
Another argument is that the author does not claim to be Jesus’ brother. This argument states that if the book of James were in fact written by James the brother of Jesus, he would have identified himself that way in order to add another layer of authority to the letter. In response, James certainly could have mentioned the fact that he was the brother of Jesus but did James really need to assert that? He was already recognized as an authority over the church in Jerusalem. He does not need to add more authority to his epistle because the fact of his authority is already established. Rather than take an overly authoritative approach, James establishes his role as a servant leader right from the beginning (Jas 1:1), a reference that Donald Guthrie says is “more becoming”.[7] Ironically, this same argument can be made in support of James as the author in the sense that it is a strong argument against pseudonymous authorship. An author who wanted to add greater authority to his work by writing under the name of James the brother of Jesus, would have made that explicitly clear rather than leaving it to speculation.
Yet another argument is that the author of James does not emphasize any major teachings or events from the life of Jesus. Those who argue this point say that if James were the author, he would have mentioned doctrinal teaching and major events from the life of his Lord and brother. In response, this is not the purpose of the book of James. “Such a claim overlooks James’ purpose in writing his epistle which . . . was practical, not doctrinal.”[8] Although James may not quote directly from the teachings of Jesus, a comparison of Matthew chapters five through seven reveals that James is in fact a practical commentary on Jesus’ Sermon on the Mount. From this comparison, it is evident that the author of James knew the teachings of Jesus and referenced them in writing this epistle.
Date and Place of Writing
Any certainty on the setting for the writing of the book of James depends on James the brother of the Lord being its author. With the case having already been made that he is the author, the most reasonable conclusion is that the book of James was written from Jerusalem. This conclusion is based on the fact that James was the elder of the church in Jerusalem. While this conclusion is not 100 percent definite, and it is not outside the realm of possibility that the book was written elsewhere, this still seems to be the most logical conclusion and has consensus among scholars that affirm James as the author.[9]
James was martyred in AD 62.[10] If James is the author of the epistle, the date of writing has to be before then. Among those who support James as the author, there are two main opinions on the date of writing. One opinion is before AD 50 and the other opinion is towards the end of James’ life c. AD 62. There are several factors to be considered.
No Mention of the Fall of Jerusalem
Jerusalem was destroyed by the Romans in AD 70. Needless to say, this was a major event Jewish history. Similar to our own recent history, where you do not have to watch the news very long before you hear a reference to the September 11th attacks on the Pentagon and the World Trade Center, we would expect to hear some reference to the destruction of Jerusalem and the Temple if the book of James were written afterwards, especially for an event that would have been so very personal for James. At the very least, this pushes the date of writing back to before AD 70.
No Mention of Tension Between Jewish and Gentile Christians
There is no indication from the book of James of any controversy between Jewish and Gentile Christians similar to the events leading up to the Jerusalem Council. “The author either intentionally ignores this or else is unaware of it and both are inconceivable after it had become a burning issue.”[11] In other words, this suggests that the writing of James occurred before the Jerusalem council (before AD 50). It may be an argument from silence, but one might expect to find at least a passing mention of the controversy leading up to the Council from an elder that was on the Council.
Worldliness
James appears to be addressing Christians who have been influenced by worldliness to some extent. The thought is that this would place the writing of James closer to the end of his life because it would take more time for worldliness to invade the churches. However this argument proves not to be useful as “this consideration can really lead us nowhere in determining chronological questions.”[12] This argument is actually too subjective. Any church can succumb to worldliness, even in its early stages (see Galatians 1:6 for example).
Conclusion
None of these arguments determine a definitive date. All that can be said for certain is that James must be written before AD 62. However, the arguments that have been discussed here seem to point to a date closer to AD 50 than AD 62.
Recipients
The epistle is addressed to “the twelve tribes in the Dispersion” (1:1). By James’ use of “the twelve tribes”, we can conclude that he is writing to Jewish people. From the contents of the epistle, we can also determine that he is writing to Christians. “The over-all tone and general content of the letter rule out the possibility that it was written to unconverted people.”[13] “Dispersion,” was a term used to describe Jews who were scattered abroad beyond the land of Palestine. Two other verses in the New Testament help our understanding of this term: John 7:35 (“Does he intend to go to the Dispersion among the Greeks?”) and 1 Peter 1:1 (“To those who are elect exiles of the dispersion in Pontus, Galatia, Cappadocia, Asia, and Bithynia”). So the book of James is addressed to Jewish Christians who lived outside of Palestine.
Occasion and Purpose
The occasion and purpose of the book of James seems somewhat difficult to discern. “There is little in James to suggest a particular event or set of circumstances which might have occasioned the letter.”[14] James covers a wide variety of topics that appear unrelated, suggesting that there is a more general purpose in mind. As previously mentioned, James is a book of practical wisdom. If we think of James as a book of wisdom, we can begin to see how all of these seemingly unrelated topics have one ultimate theme, just as the book of Proverbs covers many topics and has a unifying theme. Keeping this in mind, we may also consider how the book begins and ends. “The letter opens with a discussion concerning trials and closes with an appeal to render compassionate help to the brother who wanders from the truth.”[15] It may be concluded then, that the purpose of the book of James is to provide wise, practical counsel on how Christians are to live out their faith, respond to trials, and deal with worldliness.
Summary and Commentary
Chapter 1
James begins his epistle with a greeting to the twelve tribes in the Dispersion calling himself a servant of God and of the Lord Jesus Christ (1:1). He immediately begins to encourage his readers, telling them to face trials with joy because of the lasting, character building effect that trials have (1:2-4). James affirms that wisdom comes from God and exhorts the reader that if he is lacking in wisdom to ask God in faith without doubting (1:5-6), for the one who doubts is unstable, double-minded, and should not expect to receive anything from God (1:6-8). James then makes a slight transition, addressing wealth in order to put his argument into an eternal perspective. He encourages both the poor brother and the rich brother not to focus on earthly riches, for they are fleeting. In Christ they are on the same level, for if they remain steadfast under trial, their eternal riches will be the inheritance of the crown of life (1:9-12). Paul goes on to say that temptation and trials must not be confused. Trials are used by God, but temptation comes not from God, but from a man’s own sinful desires (1:13-15). Concluding this line of thought on trials, James affirms that every good and perfect gift, including trials (implicit from the context), comes from God. Even the gift of life is provided by God’s unchangeable will, through his word of truth (1:16-18).
Next, James transitions to the relationship between hearing and doing the Word of God. Christians must eager to hear the word, receive the word, put away all that is opposed to the word, and be doers of the word (1:19-21). Anyone who only hears the word but does not do it is deceived. James compares this deception to one who examines himself in the mirror. The one who examines himself in the “mirror” of God’s Word yet does nothing deceives himself. The one who looks into the word and responds by doing will be blessed (1:21-25). In fact, James warns those who are not doers that their religion is vain and that true religion is characterized by doing; such as visiting orphans and widows and guarding oneself against worldliness (1:25-28).
Practical Ideas
1. In all areas of our life we need to stay focused on the big picture. We can rejoice and take comfort in the fact that God is in control and he is ultimately for us. If our focus is too narrow, too concerned with the here and now, we will become easily discouraged when we face trials and easily discontented with our circumstances. Looking to the big picture of God’s eternal purposes, we can rejoice in trials knowing that God uses trials in our lives to help us to grow spiritually. We can be content in our circumstances knowing that we will ultimately receive our eternal reward which is eternal life.
2. It is important that we hear the Word of God but even more important than hearing God’s Word, we must obey by doing what it says. In Matthew 7 – the corresponding passage to James’ exhortation here – Jesus calls the man who hears his words and does not do them a fool (Matt 7:25). As we will see as the book of James develops, if we are not doers of the word, our faith is dead. True faith, “religion that is pure and undefiled before God” (1:27) is faith that is lived out in works of righteousness. It is not just keeping commandments; it is visiting widows, caring for orphans, and giving to the poor. In other words, doing God’s Word means loving and serving others just as Jesus Christ would.
Chapter 2
Once again drawing on the theme of the rich and the poor, James rebukes those who would show favoritism toward the rich man (2:1-4). James applies this principle to the character of God who has chosen the poor to be “rich in faith and heirs of the kingdom” (2:5). In fact, James exposes the foolishness of showing favoritism to the rich, for they are often the ones who are oppressors of the poor and blaspheme the name of God (2:6-7). Showing partiality is in direct contradiction to Jesus’ command to love your neighbor, and if you fail to observe this point of the law, you fail to observe the whole law. James says furthermore that the one who does not show mercy will likewise be shown no mercy at judgment. In other words, showing no mercy is equal to not doing the Word of God, and not doing the Word of God is evidence of faith that is dead (2:8-13).
Building on this idea, James says that to have faith without works is of no value. It is not saving faith, for it lacks the fruit that is evidence of true faith (2:14-17). To illustrate the difference, James points out that even the demons believe in God and shudder before him. In contrast, Abraham’s faith was active along with his works and shown by his obedience. James says this is why the Scriptures say that Abraham’s belief was counted to him as righteousness. Likewise, Rahab’s faith was proved by her works when she assisted the spies of Joshua (2:18-25). In fact, James says “faith apart from works is dead” (2:26), and that “a person is justified by works and not by faith alone” (2:24).
We must address an important issue at this point. Does James’ teaching contradict Paul when Paul says we are justified by faith (Rom 3:28; 5:1, Gal 2:16, 3:24)? An important distinction must be made here. Paul said that no one is justified by works of the law (Rom 3:20). James was talking about works of righteousness which are the result of true faith. In other words, Paul said that no one can secure salvation for themselves by keeping the law, while James said that saving faith produces faithfulness. James never suggested that good works secure saving faith. Likewise, Paul never suggested that saving faith does not result in good works.
Practical Ideas
1. Remembering that God has shown no favoritism towards us, we likewise should not show favoritism. Imagine if God’s purpose was not to save people from every tongue, tribe, and nation. Imagine if he only ever intended to save the Jewish people. If that were the case, most of us would have no hope. Praise God that the blood of Christ has “ransomed people for God from every tribe and language and people and nation” (Rev 5:9)! He has shown no partiality and has redeemed his people, not because they deserve it, but because he is faithful. As followers of Christ, let us also show no partiality towards others, but instead show mercy to all people regardless of age, race, nationality, social status or religious background.
2. Knowing that faith without works is dead is crucial, but what do we do with this knowledge? As Paul said, we must examine ourselves to see whether we are in the faith (2 Cor 13:5). Look at the examples of Abraham and Rahab. They were willing to sacrifice everything to follow the Lord. As we have already seen, being a doer of the word is more than just keeping at set of rules. We must be willing to serve the Lord sacrificially. So let us examine ourselves. Is there anything in our lives that we are clinging to that is keeping us from doing the will of God? If so, will we be willing to lay it aside and follow him? Let us always pray that God will help us to walk in living faith.
Chapter 3
Chapter three begins with James’ warning that not many should become teachers because they will be held to a higher standard in judgment, and because we all sin in many ways (3:1-2). The prime example he gives is our speech. James says that if anyone does not stumble in what he says, he is perfect and able to control the rest of his body (3:2). He compares the power the tongue has over the body to a bit in a horse’s mouth, the rudder that guides a mighty ship, or a forest fire that is started by a small flame. Likewise, James says that the tongue left unchecked is a force that has the power to defile our whole body and even destroy the course of our entire life (3:3-6). James goes to warn us that we must keep constant watch over our speech because the tongue cannot be tamed like man has tamed wild beasts and because it has the power to wound like a deadly poison (3:7-8). James laments that ungodly speech is inconsistent and incompatible with the speech that that ought to come from believers. If we bless God with our speech, how then could we turn right around and verbally attack a brother who is made in the image of God? James says that these things should not be so (3:9-10). Finally, James uses an illustration to show how our speech ultimately comes from what is in our heart. Just like a fig tree does not bear olives or a salt pond cannot yield fresh water, a wicked heart cannot produce loving speech (3:11-12).
Next, James writes about true wisdom. James says that if someone is wise and understanding, his wisdom will show in his conduct and with humbleness (3:13). He compares true wisdom that is of God and false, earthly wisdom which he calls demonic. False wisdom produces jealousy, selfish ambition, and disorder. True wisdom is pure, peaceable, and produces the fruit of righteousness (3:14-18).
Practical Ideas
1. We have seen from this chapter how destructive ungodly speech can be. Knowing this, we should apply the apostle Paul’s teaching when he say, “Let no corrupting talk come out of your mouths, but only such as is good for building up” (Eph 4:29a). We ought to be disciplined and intentional in our speech, speaking with gracious words so that we may build one another up in love.
2. We should strive for godly wisdom by honestly examining ourselves by the words in this chapter and see whether we are following false worldly wisdom, or true godly wisdom. If our conduct does not measure of to the fruits of godly wisdom, we are lacking in true wisdom. As we have already seen from James chapter one, if we lack wisdom, we should seek God in prayer and ask God for wisdom.
Chapter 4
In chapter four, James gives us a clear picture of how false worldly wisdom manifests itself. It results in sinful passions, hostility, and covetousness, which in turn results in compromise or as James puts it, “friendship” with the world (4:1-4). James says that friendship with the world is opposed to God and one who is a friend of the world is actually God’s enemy (4:4). God is a jealous God who created us with a spirit that should not be divided between him and the world (4:5). The remedy against worldliness is to humbly submit to God for his grace. God will draw near to and exalt those who are repentant and turn to him (4:6-10).
Moving on, James once again warns his readers of the dangers of slanderous speech which is opposed to the law (4:11). “The reference is likely to the royal law of 2:8: ‘Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself’ [KJV].”[16] James says that one who disobeys this law sets himself above the law as judge of the law and is not a doer of the law. However, there is only one lawgiver and judge (he implies the lawgiver and judge is God). In other words, no man has any business speaking evil against his brother (4:11-12).
At the conclusion of chapter four, James rebukes the practice of boasting about future plans apart from God. He reminds the reader that our lives are but a vapor. Such boasting is arrogant and we ought to acknowledge that God is in control of the future. Whoever fails in this regard but knows it is the right thing to do sins (4:13-17).
Practical Ideas
1. If friendship with the world is enmity with God, we ought to be on our guard to not compromise with the world. This does not mean that we should shun the world completely and go start a monastic community. God created the world and we can and should enjoy all that he has created. We are also called to evangelize the world with the gospel. C. J. Mahaney has written, “The world we are not to love is the organized human civilization that is actively hostile to God and alienated from God.”[17] Like Paul says in Romans 12:2, we must not be “conformed to the image of this world.” We cannot allow ourselves to be influenced by that which is at enmity with God. We must test everything by the standard of God’s Word.
2. Draw near to God. In humbleness, let us submit ourselves to God’s will and seek his face in prayer and repentance. Psalm 51 says that God will never despise a broken and contrite spirit. It is when we approach God with a spirit of humility and true brokenness over our sin that James say that God will exalt us. When we do this, God will give “more grace” (4:6). When we draw near to God, God will draw near to us.
Chapter 5
At the beginning of chapter five, James rebukes the wealthy who have abused their wealth to oppress the poor (5:1-6). But seeing as how unrighteous wealthy people who oppress the poor are not who James is writing to, he is probably using this rebuke to make a point to his Jewish Christian audience. James writes, “Your riches have rotted and your garments are moth-eaten” (5:2). Therefore, it would not be unreasonable to conclude that James was warning them of the foolishness of coveting or putting confidence in wealth.
In verse six, James writes that the righteous person “does not resist” the unrighteous oppressor. This seems to be a reference to Jesus’ words: “Do not resist the one who is evil. But if anyone slaps you on the right cheek, turn to him the other also” (Matt 5:39). This is where James transitions into encouraging his Christian brothers to endure suffering with patience. As we patiently wait the return of Christ, we are to remain steadfast and not grumble against each other (5:7-9). James writes that for encouragement, we can look at the example of the prophets and Job. They all endured great suffering but remained steadfast. Despite their hardship, James calls them blessed (5:10-11a). We can take comfort in the fact that God is merciful and full of compassion and he is accomplishing his purposes even in our suffering (5:11b).
In addition to enduring trials with patience, James says that we are to avoid swearing oaths (5:12a). James is clearly recalling Jesus’ teaching on the frivolous nature of swearing: “Do not take an oath by your head, for you cannot make one hair white or black” (Matt 5:36). We cannot make our word anymore true or trustworthy by swearing an oath. Jesus said that will we give an account for every careless word we speak (Matt 12:36). Our words should true and trustworthy; otherwise we may be liable to judgment for swearing false oaths (5:12b).
Next, James writes about prayer. We should be prayerful in all situations: in suffering, when cheerful, when sick, and when we have sinned. When we are sick, we should call for the elders of the church to pray for us. We should also confess our sins to each other and pray for one another (5:13-16a). The prayers of the righteous should not be underestimated, for there is much power in the prayer of even one righteous person (5:16b-18).
Finally, James ends his letter with a plea to rescue those who have wandered away from truth (5:19-20). James has given a great deal of attention to the theme of living faith versus dead faith throughout this epistle. James is most likely speaking of people who have professed to be Christians but whose faith is actually dead. “‘Among you’ [5:19a] indicates they are in the believing church professing salvation. And every pastor knows the heartbreak caused by those who profess Christ yet turn their backs on Him.”[18] They may have at one point been close to the truth, but they have continued to wander away. James would have us pray for these people and share the gospel with them so they might truly repent, have their sins forgiven, and be saved from spiritual death (5:20b).
Practical Ideas
1. We are commanded in this passage to be longsuffering and patient in enduring hardship. James says that the righteous person does not resist the oppressor (5:6b). It is not our place to retaliate or seek retribution against those who would oppress or persecute us. Vengeance belongs to God and he will vindicate the righteous when Christ returns (Rom 12:9). Until then, we are called to be steadfast while we endure suffering and anticipate the day that Christ returns (5:7).
2. As Christians, it is absolutely vital that we be people of prayer. In all seasons of our lives, we should pray without ceasing (1 Thess 5:17). James also reminds us that not only should we pray, but we should ask in faith (1:6), with confident expectation that God will answer. So let us always seek the Lord in prayer, and let us never underestimate the power of prayer, for God listens and he answers.
[1]John MacArthur, James The MacArthur New Testament Commentary (Chicago, IL: Moody Publishers, 1998), 2.
[2]All Scripture references are from the English Standard Version (ESV) unless otherwise stated.
[3]D.A. Carson, Douglas J. Moo, Leon Morris, An Introduction to the New Testament (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 1992), 410.
[5]John MacArthur, James The MacArthur New Testament Commentary (Chicago, IL: Moody Publishers, 1998), 3.
[6]Donald Guthrie, New Testament Introduction, 4th ed. (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity, 1990), 734.
[8]John MacArthur, James The MacArthur New Testament Commentary (Chicago, IL: Moody Publishers, 1998), 4.
[9]MacArthur, Carson, Moo, and Morris affirm their support for Jerusalem as the place of writing in the aforementioned sources.
[10]According to Josephus (Antiquities, XX, 9. I).
[11]Donald Guthrie, New Testament Introduction, 4th ed. (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity, 1990), 750.
[13]Curtis Vaughn, James Founders Study Guide Commentary (Cape Coral, FL: Founders Press, 2003), 15.
[17]C. J. Mahaney, Worldliness: Resisting the Seduction of a Fallen World (Wheaton, IL: Crossway Books, 2008), 25.
[18]John MacArthur, James The MacArthur New Testament Commentary (Chicago, IL: Moody Publishers, 1998), 285.